Saturday, November 12, 2011

US Income Inequality And Pareto Distributions

My comment to The Wall Street Journal article, "Income Ladder's Sticky Steps" by Carl Bialiki:
Income and wealth follow mathematical rules known as power law distributions, as noticed by the economist Vilfredo Pareto over 100 years ago. More familiarly, people know these rules as the 80-20 rule. For example, twenty percent of customers produce 80 percent of sales, etc.

These types of income distributions have several characteristics. They are scale free -- meaning that sub-parts have the same characteristics. For example in the top 10 percent of wealth or income, the top 20 percent of that group will have 80 percent of the income or wealth. The same is true for the top 1 percent or the bottom 10 percent.

While the exact break down can vary and need not be exactly 80-20 (can be 80-30 or 70-10 for example), all economies, at all times, have unequal concentrations of wealth and income. For example, 20 percent of countries produce about 82 percent of GDP.

The US Income Pareto distribution changes over time. The inequality levels, as measured by a Pareto distribution were high around 1920 and are about the same level as now. Pareto inequality declined from 1920 until around the 1970's and started to increase again until the beginning of the recession. No one has a good answer as to why income level distributions have been cyclical over the last 100 years, or whether it will continue its trend towards more income and wealth concentration or reverse as it did in the 1970s.

Power law distributions are a fundamental rule of nature, just like the binomial distribution.

Networks and Internet sites also follow power law rules and 20 percent of sites get 80 percent of traffic. So do many other natural, sociological and economic phenomena.

Why?

As an example, think of all the aspiring singers and rock groups, or high school and college football and basketball players. Only a few will get professional contracts and of those, only a few will become stars with multi-million dollar salaries. Think of mom and pop stores. How many will become a Wal-Mart?

Should governments ban us from shopping at the large national chains because of their concentration of sales and forced us to shop at stores with higher prices, older merchandise, and tougher return policies? Should we have to buy music from groups we do not like because their song sales are low? Should we have to use doctors that are not the ones recommended by our friends and families because too many people use those doctors and ignore the others? Should we have to watch professional sports teams that use players that otherwise would not be selected?

Our daily consumption choices create much of the wealth and income concentration.

Should someone who can take a mom and pop store, turn it into a Wal-Mart and expand its sales a million or more fold get paid the same amount as someone whose local store never expands its locations, items it carries or goes out of business? Should a quarterback, who loses most of his games and throws lots of interceptions, get paid the same amount as a quarterback who can consistently win and take his team to the Superbowl?

Pareto distributions (power laws) have another characteristic. If the leaders are eliminated, other leaders form. If you eliminate the top income earners, top internet sites, top musical groups, top doctors, etc., other earners, sites, groups and doctors will become the top 20 percent garnering 80 percent.

It is our natural tendency to be social animals; herded like sheep, into the same music, clothes, movies, cars, etc. that creates wealth and income concentration. It is also the entrepreneurial spirit of the US to reward success, while inwardly we harbor jealousy and beliefs that under the right circumstances, we too could have achieved that level of success.

61 comments :

  1. "No one has a good answer as to why income level distributions have been cyclical over the last 100 years, or whether it will continue its trend towards more income and wealth concentration or reverse as it did in the 1970s."

    My jaw hit the floor when I read that. It would seem that even some very well read people have no idea that the economy grew more than twice as much under 12 years of FDR as under the last 48 years of Republican presidents combined.

    It would seem that the idea that you need a strong middle class in which capital owners and labor have relatively balanced power and influence in society in order to simultaneously provide both the capital growth and demand growth that must come hand in hand to have a strong society.

    ReplyDelete
  2. sf_jeff

    First, correlation does not prove causality - a key concept you need to know before looking at any form of statistic.

    Second, you seem to discount the impact of WWII. This was the main kick start for economic growth in the U.S. and continued long after as much of the world was stuck rebuilding while we were not. We were the suppliers of that rebuild and benefitted greatly during the subsequent few decades.

    There is still zero proof that without WWII, FDR's socialist programs would have gotten the US out of the economic cycle it was in any sooner than any other form of policy.

    In fact, looking at Japan and how they have been trying to do the same thing for that last 20 years from their lost decade and they are still lost, the reality is that any program, either democratic or republican would have failed to produce much if not for the war.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Here we provide sexy and genuine Mumbai Escorts who not only ready to give you immense love but also ready to give you reliable facilities and service which will definitely change your mood. if you to more about us. visit here
    Mumbai Escort Service

    ReplyDelete
  4. Aisha paal pune escorts extending elite female model Escort services in cheapest rates. Call or meeting for best pune escort service. Group of independent Call Girls available on demand in pune

    ReplyDelete
  5. If you truly need to go caressed then what could be more appealing than the aid of those escorts in Jaipur. Just employ an escort out of Jaipur Escort Service and prepare to get a challenging drive in the business of the magic beauties. All these gorgeous ladies won't just guarantee you sleepless evenings but may also provide you a few of the won't unforgettable moments on your lifetime.
    Jaipur escorts
    Escorts in Jaipur
    Jaipur escorts service
    Udaipur escorts
    Jodhpur escorts
    Ajmer escorts
    jaisalmer escorts
    Pushkar escorts
    Kishangarh escorts

    ReplyDelete
  6. In this situation you might wonder how it might efficiently be used. But as soon as you do and take out it you'll automatically come to understand. The women who'd function you're always there accessible awaiting you.
    Nainital escorts
    Bareilly escorts
    Haldwani escorts
    RudraPur escorts
    Ramnagar Call Girls
    Bhimtal escorts
    Dehradun escorts
    Haridwar escorts
    Rishikesh escorts
    Mussorie escorts

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello, My Dearest Friends Super class independent Escorts Services available incall & outcall service in VIP hotels. and call girls available for booking 24x7 hours IF You want Physical Relationship any time contact me & ?meet with me to get my number from website and call
    Thank You & Visit Again""_____

    |Escorts In Gurgaon |
    |Escorts In Mumbai |
    |Call Girls In Gurgaon|

    |Call Girl In Mumbai |
    |Call Girl In Gurgaon |

    |Gurgaon Escorts |
    |Gurgaon Escorts |

    |Gurgaon Call Girl |
    |Call Girl In Andheri |

    |Gurgaon Call Girls |
    |Escorts In Gurgaon |

    |Escorts In Bangalore |
    |Call girls In Bangalore |

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi My Name is Alisha Petel at I read your all Blog. Your blog is very informative. I have a feminine supple

    body, full perky breasts, sensitive nipples that love the touch of firm hands and a nice wet tongue. http://puneindependentescorts.com/ I'm a really passionate

    European girl with big sex drive and I just can not get enough. When and where you want, our friendly and

    beautiful Escorts are there for you with their in-call or out call services. For more details please visit

    here.Thank You for Sharing Blog.


    Pune escorts

    Bangalore Escorts

    Mumbai Escorts

    Sex services in Mumbai

    Koregaon park Escorts

    Escorts Girl in Mumbai Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  9. Welcome to VIP Escorts in Mumbai. In this escorts Provider agency, you will get Escorts in Mumbai. VIP Escorts is a standout amongst the most confided in escorts Provider Group and one of the greatest Escorts Agency in Mumbai. Here are the genuine Profiles of our Hottest and High-level Escorts in Mumbai for our very much arranged Customers.
    Visit Mumbai Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  10. Surat escorts || Surat escort || Surat escorts services || Surat escorts services || escorts in Surat || escorts service in Surat || independent Surat escorts || Surat call girls || call girls in Surat || Surat model escorts || Surat female escorts || Surat dating escorts || Surat vip escorts || sexy call girls number in Surat || Surat call girls number || Surat girls whatsapp number || call girls facebook in Surat || Surat escorts agency || Surat dating escorts || Surat escorts girls || Surat cheap escorts || high class Surat escorts || Surat model escorts || bollywood call girls number in Surat || dance call girs number in Surat || Surat desi escorts || Surat sexy girls || top videos dance in Surat || Surat sexy dance || boys and girls sexy dance in Surat || Surat hot call girls ||

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. After See Your Niche I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.

    My Name Is Priya Singh. I Run My Own Mumbai Escorts Service. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Am Beautiful And Hot. My Service Charge Is Low And Service Is Super. Being Professional I Have Seven Years’ Experience As An Escort Girl. So I Understand And Feel The Real Needs And Requirement Of My Each Client. You Can Taste Me Any Time. According The Convenience You Can Avail My VIP Escort Service At Your Home Or In Hotel Also. To Book My VIP Mumbai Escort Service Call +91 9987215552. Visit http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com/


    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mumbai Escorts In Vile Parle
    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts
    Escort Service In Colaba

    ReplyDelete
  12. I Saw Your Website Carefully. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. Your All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. I Say Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also. I Am Ritu Sharma. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Deal In Mumbai Escorts service. I Am Very Hot And Sexy. Being A Mumbai Escort Girl I Have Five Years’ Experience. That’s Why I Understand The Each Personal Needs Of My Every Client. My Service Charge Is Low And Service Is Super. You Can Avail My VIP Mumbai Escorts Service At Your Home Or In Hotel. I Am Comfortable To Provide Mumbai Escorts Service In Local And Outside Also. Visit www.escortservicemumbai.net Call +91- 9OO4OO9481
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mumbai Escorts In Vile
    Parle

    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts

    Mumbai Escorts In Colaba

    ReplyDelete
  13. WELCOME TO VIP ESCORTS IN GURGAON

    Looking for hot personality women of Gurgaon? Then you are exactly at proper area. Here in Gurgaon Escorts which is also referred to as Gurgaon Escorts giving you that kind of grownup provider which your lust continually want from you. I recognize you are very depressed from this antique recurring boring life. You need to take some damage out of your work load. Then it's far the best location wherein all of your tiredness might be vanish faraway from your body and mind in few minutes. Our Gurgaon girl escorts will provide you with that sort of fine service which you may by no means neglect to your life ever.
    Call Girls In Gurgaon
    Best Call Girls In Gurgaon
    Call Girl In Gurgaon
    Call Girls service In Gurgaon
    Gurgaon call girls services
    Gurgaon Call Girlss
    Gurgaon Escorts Services
    Gurgaon Escorts Services
    independent Escorts Services in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  14. Call Girls services in Gurgaon is of great quality and experience, the high level of expertise in the Call Girls service providers contributed to enhancing the quality of their service provision to the people. Competitive call girls service providers in Gurgaon can also be viewed to have influenced the level of best services offered to customers in this city in terms of each call girls service providers trying all their possible best to offer more quality service compared to their counter-part.
    Call Girls In Gurgaon
    Independent Escort Services
    Best Escorts Gurgaon
    Independent Gurgaon Call Girls
    Call : +91 8587837371

    ReplyDelete
  15. #jaipur escorts, #jaipur escorts, #jaipur escorts, #jaipur escorts, #jaipur escorts, #jaipur escorts

    #fucker , #porn fucker , Fuck Sexy Girls , Fuck Sexy Girl , Fuck Girls , I love Fuck Girls , I Like fuck Girls , Fucker Girls in Jaipur #Jaipur escort service , #Jaipur escort service , #Jaipur escort fucking , #fucking Jaipur escorts Relly love to fuck Jaipur escorts wanna fuck your self in Jaipur

    Find Here Best Jaipur Escorts Girls with independent Call Girls in jaipur.we Offer Best Escort Service in Jaipur With Models, Celebrity, Housewife, Collage Girls Escort in Jaipur. #jaipur escorts , #Escorts in Jaipur, #jaipur escorts service, #escorts jaipur, #jaipur esorts agency, #jaipur esort, #escorts service in jaipur

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I am Shania Dsuza, provide the escorts services in Pathankot.We have the most delicious entertaining girls. They are most helpful to their client's relaxation.
    Follow us_

    Pathankot escorts
    Patiala escorts
    Bathinda escorts
    Chandigarh escorts

    ReplyDelete
  18. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hello, My Dearest Friends Super class independent Chandigarh Escorts Services available incall & outcall service in VIP hotels in Chandigarh. and call girls available for booking 24x7 hours IF You want Physical Relationship any time contact me & ?meet with me to get my number from website and call
    Thank You & Visit Again""_____
    Chandigarh escorts
    Mohali escorts
    Panchkula escorts
    Zirakpur escorts
    Kharar escorts
    Jalandhar escorts
    Ludhiana escorts

    ReplyDelete
  20. Enjoy your happy moments with our ahmedabad call girls escorts. We are provide you VIP female call girls with very cheap rate in all over India. You can call me any time in day or night. I am available for you 24X7.

    ReplyDelete

  21. Hello Friends My Name is Mahi Verma And I Am An Independent call girl living in manali and i am doing Part Time Job In Mahi Escorts Agency Here Is Lot Of Call Girls Avialable In this agency So U can Call Us And Book An Escorts.
    Manali Escorts
    Manali Call Girls
    Escorts In Manali
    Call Girls In Manali

    ReplyDelete
  22. Karol Bagh escorts service – Call 9711199171- Enjoy with the most gorgeous call girls in Karol Bagh, we provide you the best VIP escorts service, collage girl services at lowest rates. For more details visit my website:-
    Dwarka escorts service
    Karol Bagh call girl
    Call girl in Mahipalpur
    Nehru Place escorts
    Indepenendent Saket escorts
    Nehru Place escorts service
    Saket call girl
    Call girl in Mahipalpur
    Dwarka escorts
    Indepenendent Karol Bagh escorts

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete